Just spent a week as chief judge for the
Automobile Association Motoring Excellence Awards. With 60 cars entered in
eight categories, it was pretty full on.
Any car currently on sale is eligible,
though companies only enter those they think have a chance of winning. Still,
the judges often miss something they think should have been entered; this year
it was Nissan’s 370Z. Surely its handsome good looks and phenomenal
bang-for-buck made it a performance class contender? Clearly Nissan thought not.
Meantime we were left to evaluate
everything from the $18,990 Barina Spark to a $254,000 Audi A8.
How to judge between such widely diverse
cars? We look not only at performance, design and handling, but how well each
car performs the task for which it’s designed, and its value. A $40,000 compact
might do a better job than a $20,000 competitor, but is it twice as good?
Come the finals, when we’re judging the winners
from each bracket against each other, we also must consider how far a car
pushes what’s expected from its bracket.
So a $35,000 compact that over-delivers
for its class and price can beat a $135,000 executive car which doesn’t.
The result? No idea. Watch out for the
announcement on December 3.
(Photo: Mike Stephen)
|